Last week, something historic happened in the world of food testing — and much of the English-speaking internet has missed it entirely.
Stiftung Warentest, Germany’s leading independent consumer-testing organization — founded by the government in 1964, now fully self-funded through publications, with zero advertiser influence — put vegan and beef burger patties head to head. Ten of each. A controlled, evidence-based comparison.
The result
Vegan patties came out on top, and it wasn’t particularly close:
1) Overall rating
Seven out of ten plant-based patties rated “good.” Only three out of ten beef patties did.
The three top-scoring burgers came from Aldi MyVay, Garden Gourmet, and Beyond — and they were all vegan.
This is a dramatic reversal from the last time this test was run in 2021, when meat still held the edge. The improvement in plant-based products over just a few years has been remarkable.
2) Fats
Vegan patties averaged 43% less fat and 20% fewer calories than their beef counterparts — and the fat they do contain skews toward the healthy, unsaturated kind, while beef patties lean heavily on saturated fat.
3) Taste
Plant-based options scored better on average for seasoning, juiciness, and overall cooking results. Some beef patties, meanwhile, showed up with off-putting smells, flat flavors, and shelf-life issues.
The evaluation was conducted through an anonymised blind tasting, with trained assessors reviewing the patties without knowing which were vegan and which were beef. All products were prepared under identical conditions.
4) Food safety
Antibiotic-resistant bacteria were found in 40% of the beef patties tested. One contained genuinely pathogenic bacteria. The vegan patties? Zero contaminants.
5) Price
The vegan patties were, on average, 20% cheaper than beef. And that’s before accounting for the massive government subsidies that artificially deflate the price of conventional meat. Without those subsidies, the gap would be even wider.
This test didn’t happen in a vacuum
These results, while remarkable, land at a moment when a balanced vegan diet is already demonstrably healthier and less expensive than consuming animal products. Plant-based food is getting better, more convenient, and more affordable at the same time — a combination that the animal industry has no real answer to.
Vegan products will keep improving. The price gap will keep growing. The excuses will keep running out. At some point — and that point is getting closer — choosing to support unnecessary animal suffering will require active, conscious effort to justify. It won’t be about convenience, or taste, or cost. Those arguments are already crumbling.
The question of whether the animal industry will collapse under the weight of all this is no longer if. It’s when.
Vegan Horizon is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts straight to your inbox and support my work, consider joining as a free or paid subscriber.
I’ve never thought vegan food was bad or too expensive. I’ve been eating it for over 13 years..
I have tasted many types of vegan burgers and find them all to possess appeal. 🙂 Thank you sharing this important information, Pala. 🌟